| The
relationship between science and spirituality is complex
– but it’s not as hostile as the Galileo controversy
and the creation/evolution debate make it seem.
Science offers spirituality new
models of how the world works and new ways of
seeing the world. A scientific
model isn’t the truth about something: it’s
a useful picture that explains the results we have and
accurately predicts the results we’ll get. For
example, light is a wave-particle. It’s actually
neither or both, or something else altogether, but the
model works. Ideas like light’s
duality and quantum
uncertainty excite our minds and give spirituality
new approaches and metaphors. Of course it’s important
to understand the model, to know when something is just
a metaphor, and when it’s a total myth –
which is part of what the blog will explore.
Spirituality offers science a
safe haven for unproven ideas. Sometimes things
work, but we don’t know why yet. An “operative
fiction” is similar to a scientific
model: it works (operative) but it’s not necessarily
true (fiction). Believing you will get well, against
all the scientific evidence, can improve your health
– the placebo effect. The opposite is also true:
the nocebo effect means you can die from being cursed
or wrongly diagnosed with cancer.
Some ideas which spirituality
and “old wives’ tales” kept safe have
now been proven. The “superstitious”
“unhygienic” practice of putting moldy bread
on wounds, for example, was – of course –
penicillin. Some are difficult to prove – for
example, the idea that the full moon makes people crazy,
“lunacy”. Despite massive anecdotal evidence,
for years studies could find no link. Now, researchers
have found a correlation with seizures, at least.
Of course, the two argue –
mainly about how you know something is true.
Science demands that a theory must be falsifiable:
you must be able to test whether it’s true or
not. On the other hand, spirituality questions whether
the scientific
method is effective for all things – what
if that way of thinking actually stops something working?

|